›› 2011, Vol. 32 ›› Issue (S1): 209-216.

• Fundamental Theroy and Experimental Research • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comparative analyses of several rock strength criteria

SHI Xiang-chao, MENG Ying-feng, LI Gao   

  1. State Key Laboratory of Oil and Gas Reservoir Geology and Exploitation, Southwest Petroleum University, Chengdu 610500, China
  • Received:2010-12-21 Online:2011-05-15 Published:2011-05-16

Abstract: Least mean standard fitting deviation is used as an evaluation index; we analyze the applicability of five conventional triaxial strength criteria to describe the nonlinear strength characteristics of rocks based on test data of ten rocks cited from public literatures. It is obvious that linear Mohr-Coulomb criterion can’t describe the nonlinear strength characteristics of rocks. Parabolic Mohr-Coulomb criterion can describe the nonlinearity feature of rock strength; but for the reason that the fitting error is very great and the parameters from calculation is not consistent with the real data; so it is not suitable to apply parabolic Mohr-Coulomb criterion in geotechnical engineering. For the nonlinear strength characteristics of rocks at low-to-moderate confining pressure level( ), the Bieniawski criterion with a single parameter and Hoek-Brown Criterion is better than Bieniawski Criterion with two parameters; their fitting accuracy is close to exponential strength criterion with three parameters; but they can’t be used at high confining level. When nonlinear strength characteristics are very significant under high confining pressure, the fitting deviations of Bieniawski criterion with three parameters and exponential strength criterion with three parameters are smaller; so they can be used to evaluate the strength under high geostress

Key words: strength criterion of rocks, nonlinear strength characteristics of rocks, applicability of strength criterion, least mean standard fitting deviation

CLC Number: 

  • TU 452
[1] GUO Liang, HU Xie-wen, LI Xiao-zhao, WU Xi-yong, WU Li-zhou, LI Yu, LUO Gang, MA Hong-sheng,. Experimental study of hydraulic characteristics of undisturbed fractured rock in granite fault zone [J]. , 2018, 39(11): 3937-3948.
[2] ZHANG Xi-wei, WANG Gang, CAI Ming, XU Quan,. Deformation behaviour and brittleness of Linghai granite [J]. , 2018, 39(10): 3515-3524.
[3] CHEN Song, QIAO Chun-sheng, YE Qing, DENG Bin. Composite damage constitutive model of rock mass with intermittent joints based on Mohr-Coulomb criterion [J]. , 2018, 39(10): 3612-3622.
[4] LI Xiao-fei, SUN Jiang-tao, CHEN Wei-zhong, YUAN Jing-qiang, LIU Jin-quan, ZHANG Qing-yan,. Strength and anti-washout property of fiber silica fume cement grout [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3157-3163.
[5] LI Shu-cai, PAN Dong-dong, XU Zhen-hao, LI Li-ping, LIN Peng,. A model test on catastrophic evolution process of water inrush of a concealed karst cave filled with confined water [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3164-3173.
[6] LI Dong-qi, LI Zong-li, Lü Cong-cong. Analysis of fracture strength of rock mass considering fissure additional water pressure [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3174-3180.
[7] ZUO Yu-jun, SUN Wen-ji-bin, WU Zhong-hu, XU Yun-fei, . Experiment on permeability of shale under osmotic pressure and stress coupling [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3253-3260.
[8] WANG Feng-yun, QIAN De-ling. Elasto-plastic analysis of a deep circular tunnel based on tangential strain softening [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3313-3320.
[9] FU Yan, YUAN Wen, LIU Xin-rong, MIAO Lou-li, XIE Wen-bo,. Deterioration rules of strength parameters of sandstone under cyclical wetting and drying in acid-based environment [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3331-3339.
[10] LIU Quan-sheng, PENG Xing-xin, HUANG Xing, LEI Guang-feng, WEI Lai, LIU He,. Monitoring shield stress of tunnel boring machine and jamming warning [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3406-3414.
[11] ZHENG An-xing, LUO Xian-qi,. An extended finite element method for modeling hydraulic fracturing in perilous rock [J]. , 2018, 39(9): 3461-3468.
[12] WU Yong-sheng, TAN Zhong-sheng, YU Xian-bin, YU Yu, ZHU Yong,. Dilatancy behavior of phyllite in uniaxal compressive tests under different loading azimuths [J]. , 2018, 39(8): 2747-2754.
[13] LI Shuai, ZHU Wan-cheng, NIU Lei-lei, LI Ru-fei, LI Shao-hua. Experimental study on influence of dynamic disturbance on deformation behavior of rock under stress relaxation [J]. , 2018, 39(8): 2795-2804.
[14] WANG Fei-li, WANG Shu-hong, XIU Zhan-guo. Method on stress quantification and strength characterization of rock structural plane under the disturbance of stress wave [J]. , 2018, 39(8): 2844-2850.
[15] LI Yang, SHE Cheng-xue. Numerical simulation of effect of size on crushing strength of rockfill grains using particle flow code [J]. , 2018, 39(8): 2951-2959.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
[1] GONG Wei-li, AN Li-qian, ZHAO Hai-yan, MAO Ling-tao. Multiple scale characterization of CT image for coal rock fractures based on image description[J]. , 2010, 31(2): 371 -376 .
[2] WAN Zhi, DONG Hui, LIU Bao-chen. On choice of hyper-parameters of support vector machines for time series regression and prediction with orthogonal design[J]. , 2010, 31(2): 503 -508 .
[3] GAO Guang-yun, ZHAO Yuan-yi, GAO Meng, YANG Cheng-bin. Improved calculation for lateral dynamic impedance of pile groups in layered soil[J]. , 2010, 31(2): 509 -515 .
[4] SUN Xi-yuan, LUAN Mao-tian, TANG Xiao-wei. Study of horizontal bearing capacity of bucket foundation on saturated soft clay ground[J]. , 2010, 31(2): 667 -672 .
[5] WANG Ming-nian, GUO Jun, LUO Lu-sen, Yu Yu, Yang Jian-min, Tan Zhon. Study of critical buried depth of large cross-section loess tunnel for high speed railway[J]. , 2010, 31(4): 1157 -1162 .
[6] TAN Feng-yi, Jiang Zhi-quan, Li Zhong-qiu, YAN Hui-he. Application of additive mass method to testing compacted density of filling material in Kunming new airport[J]. , 2010, 31(7): 2214 -2218 .
[7] CHAI Bo, YIN Kun-long, XIAO Yong-jun. Characteristics of weak-soft zones of Three Gorges Reservoir shoreline slope in new Badong county[J]. , 2010, 31(8): 2501 -2506 .
[8] WANG Xue-wu,XU Shang-jie,DANG Fa-ning,CHENG Su-zhen. Analysis of stability of dam slope during rapid drawdown of reservoir water level[J]. , 2010, 31(9): 2760 -2764 .
[9] WANG Wei-ming, SUN Rui, CAO Zhen-zhong, YUAN Xiao-ming. Comparative study of features of liquefied sites at home and abroad[J]. , 2010, 31(12): 3913 -3918 .
[10] WANG Guang-jin,YANG Chun-he ,ZHANG Chao,MA Hong-ling,KONG Xiang-yun ,HO. Research on particle size grading and slope stability analysis of super-high dumping site[J]. , 2011, 32(3): 905 -913 .